Cumulative Preference Shares: Meaning and Features

Cumulative preference shares offer a fixed dividend that, if unpaid in a given year, accumulates until paid out in full, ensuring priority payment over common shares. They provide investors with a more secure income stream but typically lack voting rights, making them a blend of equity and fixed-income characteristics.

Let's consider a company named "EcoGreen Energy," which issues cumulative preference shares with a 5% annual dividend. John, a small investor, decides to purchase these shares. In the first year after his investment, EcoGreen faces unexpected market challenges and is unable to pay dividends to its shareholders. 

However, because John holds cumulative preference shares, his 5% dividend for that year is not lost; it's simply deferred. The following year, EcoGreen recovers and resumes dividend payments. John then receives a 10% dividend - the accumulated 5% from the missed year and the current year's 5%. 

This ensures that even in fluctuating market conditions, John's dividends are safeguarded and paid out when the company can afford to do so. 

Check out: Online Stock Market Courses and Certifications

Table of Content

• What is Cumulative Preference Shares?
• Example of Cumulative Preference Share
• Characteristics of Cumulative Preference Shares
• Advantages of Cumulative Preference Shares
• Disadvantages of Cumulative Preference Shares

What is Cumulative Preference Shares?

Cumulative preference shares are a specific type of stock in a company that offers a blend of features from both bonds and traditional stocks. Let's break down what this means:

Shares: In general, when you own shares in a company, you own a small part of that company.

Preference Shares: Preference Shares are a special kind of share. They are called 'preference' because they give certain advantages. The most common advantage is that owners of preference shares get paid dividends (a share of the company's profits) before regular stockholders.

Cumulative: This is the unique feature of cumulative preference shares. Imagine a situation where the company doesn't make enough profit one year and can't pay dividends to its shareholders. If you own cumulative preference shares, you don't lose your dividend. 

Instead, it gets accumulated or 'carried over' to the next year. When the company can pay dividends again, you will receive your missed dividends before any dividends are paid to regular stockholders or even non-cumulative preference shareholders.

Example of Cumulative Preference Share

Imagine a company issues cumulative preference shares with a 5% annual dividend. In a tough year, the company can't afford to pay dividends. If you own these shares, you don't lose out. Instead, your 5% dividend accumulates. The next year, if the company pays dividends again, you'll first receive your accumulated 5% from the previous year, plus the current year's 5%, ensuring you get a 10% return before common shareholders see any dividends.

Characteristics of Cumulative Preference Shares

Dividend Priority: Holders of cumulative preference shares are entitled to receive dividends before common shareholders. This means if a company declares dividends, these shareholders get paid first.

Accumulation of Unpaid Dividends: If a company is unable to pay dividends in a given year, the dividends owed to cumulative preference shareholders accumulate. These accumulated dividends must be paid in full before any dividends can be paid to common shareholders in subsequent years.

Fixed Dividend Rate: The dividends for cumulative preference shares are typically set at a fixed rate. This rate is usually expressed as a percentage of the share's nominal value. This fixed rate provides a predictable income stream, unlike common shares where dividends can fluctuate.

No Voting Rights: Generally, cumulative preference shareholders do not have voting rights in company meetings. This means they cannot vote on matters like electing the board of directors or other major corporate decisions.

Preference in Assets Upon Liquidation: In the event of company liquidation, cumulative preference shareholders have priority over common shareholders when it comes to asset distribution. However, they are ranked below debt holders, such as bondholders.

Convertible Options: Some cumulative preference shares come with an option to convert them into common shares after a certain period or under specific conditions. This feature offers the potential for capital gains in addition to fixed dividend earnings.

Advantages of Cumulative Preference Shares

Predictable Income Stream

Cumulative preference shares typically offer a fixed dividend rate, providing shareholders with a predictable and steady source of income.

Example: If Laura invests in cumulative preference shares with a 5% annual dividend, she can expect a consistent return each year, adding stability to her investment portfolio.

Accumulation of Unpaid Dividends

If a company is unable to pay dividends in a given year, the dividends owed to cumulative preference shareholders accumulate and are paid out in future profitable years.

Example: Suppose a company skips dividend payments in a difficult financial year. As a holder of cumulative preference shares, Michael doesn’t lose his dividends; instead, they accumulate. When the company resumes dividend payments, Michael receives the accumulated dividends plus the current year's dividends.

Priority Over Common Shares

 In terms of dividend payments and during liquidation, cumulative preference shareholders have priority over common shareholders.

Example: In a scenario where a company decides to pay dividends or is liquidated, Emma, a cumulative preference shareholder, will receive payments before any dividends are distributed to common shareholders. This prioritization reduces her risk of losing out on dividends or claims on assets.

Reduced Investment Risk

The fixed dividend rate and preferential treatment in payments make cumulative preference shares a lower-risk investment compared to common shares.

Example: John, who prefers lower-risk investments, chooses cumulative preference shares of a stable company. Despite market fluctuations affecting common stock dividends, John's investment remains secure with guaranteed dividend payouts.

No Voting Rights (Beneficial for the Issuing Company)

Cumulative preference shares usually do not come with voting rights. This is advantageous for companies as it allows them to raise capital without diluting control.

Example: TechCorp issues cumulative preference shares to fund a new project. Since these shares don’t have voting rights, the company's existing management retains full control over company decisions, even after raising capital.

Disadvantages of Cumulative Preference Shares

Limited Growth Potential

The dividends for cumulative preference shares are usually fixed, which means they do not benefit from the company's growing profits beyond the predetermined dividend rate. This limits the growth potential of the investment compared to common shares, which might offer higher dividends and increased value as the company grows.

Impact: Investors seeking capital appreciation may find cumulative preference shares less attractive, as they primarily offer fixed income rather than growth.

No Voting Rights

Holders of cumulative preference shares typically do not have voting rights in company decisions. This lack of influence can be significant, especially in key decisions that might affect the company's direction and, consequently, the value of its investment.

Impact: Investors looking for a say in company governance and decision-making processes will find cumulative preference shares limiting.

Risk of Deferred Dividends

Although cumulative preference shares accumulate unpaid dividends, there's always a risk that if the company faces prolonged financial difficulties, these dividends may be deferred for several years. This delay can impact the investor's expected cash flow.

Impact: For investors relying on regular income from dividends, such delays can pose financial challenges and uncertainty.

Lower Priority in Liquidation Compared to Debt

In the event of liquidation, cumulative preference shareholders are ranked below debt holders, such as bondholders. This means they are paid only after all debts have been settled, which could leave little to no assets for preference shareholders in a worst-case scenario.

Impact: This poses a higher risk in terms of asset recovery compared to debt instruments, especially in situations where the company's assets are insufficient to cover all liabilities.

Callable Feature

Many cumulative preference shares are callable, meaning the issuing company can buy them back at a predetermined price after a certain date. While this can be beneficial for the company, it can be a disadvantage for investors, especially if the shares are called back during a low-interest-rate environment or when alternative investments offer lower returns.

Impact: This feature can limit the long-term income potential for investors and may force them to reinvest in a less favorable market.

Understanding

Conclusion!

Cumulative preference shares represent a unique financial instrument that blends the stability of fixed-income securities with the potential benefits of equity. They offer investors predictable returns and a safety net through accumulated dividends, with priority in payment over common shares. While they lack the growth potential of common stocks and usually don't have voting rights, their appeal lies in providing a lower-risk, income-focused investment option, making them a valuable part of a diversified investment portfolio.