Difference Between Test Cases and Test Scenarios
The main difference between test cases and test scenarios is that test cases are specific instructions for testing an application's function. Meanwhile, test scenarios describe how a function should work.
When we talk about software testing, two terms often pop up: Test Cases and Test Scenarios. While these terms may seem similar, they differ significantly in detail and focus. The primary difference between test cases and test scenarios lies in the level of detail and focus.
Test Cases are about the 'how' - they provide the exact steps for testing each part of a feature. Test Scenarios are about the 'what' - they identify the features or functions that need testing but leave the specific 'how' more open. Test Cases are like a detailed guide, while Test Scenarios are more like a summary or an objective.
Table of Contents (TOC)
- Test Cases and Test Scenarios: Comparison Table
- What is a Test Case?
- Test Case Example
- Best Practices for Creating Test Cases
- What is a Test Scenario?
- Test Scenario Example
- Best Practices for Creating Test Scenarios
- Real-Life Examples of Test Cases and Test Scenarios
- Key Differences Between Test Cases and Test Scenarios
Test Cases and Test Scenarios: Comparison Table
Benchmark |
Test Cases |
Test Scenarios |
Definition |
A detailed document, which includes testing strategy, process, preconditions, and expected output. |
A high-level classification of testable requirements, often a one-liner statement of what to test. |
Detail Level |
Low-level actions, including all positive and negative inputs, navigation steps, and expected results. |
High-level actions, more of an end-to-end functionality coverage in linear statements. |
Objective |
To verify the test scenario by implementing steps. |
To cover the end-to-end functionality of a software application. |
Time Consumption |
Takes more time compared to test scenarios. |
Takes less time compared to test cases. |
Maintenance |
Harder to maintain due to its detailed nature. |
Easier to maintain due to high-level design. |
Focus |
Focuses on "How to be tested" β the specifics of execution. |
Focuses on "What to be tested" β the broader scope of functionality. |
Resource Requirement |
Requires more resources for creation and execution. |
Fewer resources are needed for writing. |
Testing Approach |
Helps in in-depth testing of the application. |
Facilitates an Agile way of testing, focusing on overall functionality. |
Derived From |
Usually obtained from test scenarios. |
Often derived from use cases or documentation like SRS, BRS, etc. |
Ambiguity |
No ambiguity, as they define test steps, prerequisites, and expected outcomes clearly. |
Can be ambiguous due to their high-level, one-liner nature. |
Usage in Agile Methodology |
Less preferred in Agile due to its time-intensive nature. |
More preferred in Agile for quick, high-level testing in time-sensitive situations. |
Example |
Check behaviour with a valid user ID and password, check the 'Keep me signed in' functionality, etc. |
Check login functionality, payment functionality, search functionality, etc. |
Best-suited Quality Assurance & Testing courses for you
Learn Quality Assurance & Testing with these high-rated online courses
What is a Test Case?
A Test Case is a set of actions executed to verify a particular feature or functionality of a software application. In lay terms, it is like a blueprint for testers that instructs - how to test each small part of a software feature. Each Test Case includes:
- Preconditions: What needs to be in place before you start testing?
- Test Steps: Exact steps you need to follow to carry out the test.
- Expected Results: What the outcome should be if the function works correctly.
Test Case Example
Scenario: Testing the login functionality of a social media app.
- Preconditions: The user must be registered.
- Test Steps:
- Step 1: Enter a valid username and password.
- Step 2: Click the login button.
- Expected Result: The user logs in successfully and is redirected to the dashboard.
Test Case Best Practices
Here are the five best practices for creating test cases:
- Link each test case to specific requirements for clarity and relevance.
- Write transparent, user-focused test cases for straightforward execution.
- Regularly update test cases, including positive and negative conditions.
- Avoid repetition; each test case should uniquely validate a function.
- Ensure test cases are identifiable and check all specified software requirements.
What is a Test Scenario?
A Test Scenario is a high-level overview of what needs to be tested in an app or software. Unlike the detailed Test Case, it's more about the objective or goal, focusing on the end goal rather than the detailed process.
In laymanβs terms, a test scenario answers a single query, "What features or functions of the application should we test?" but doesn't break down the steps to do so. These are drawn from test artifacts like Business Requirement Specifications (BRS) and System Requirement Specifications (SRS).
Test Scenario Example
Scenario: Validate the payment process in an e-commerce application.
This scenario checks the complete payment process's functionality. But doesn't specify individual steps like - card details entry, OTP verification, payment confirmation, etc.
Test Scenario Best Practices
Here are the five best practices for creating test scenarios:
- Keep test scenarios simple, focusing on entire functionality coverage (functional testing).
- Ensure each scenario is a clear, single-line statement of the test objective.
- Regularly review scenarios to verify whether they reflect real user needs and risks.
- Prioritize scenarios based on application complexity and stakeholder requirements.
- Accumulate necessary tools and resources before testing begins for efficiency.
Real-Life Examples of Test Cases and Test Scenarios
Until now, you must have grasped the difference between test cases and test scenarios. If not, here's a real-life example to help you understand better.
Test Case: Consider a banking application where a Test Case might involve verifying the functionality of a fund transfer. It will include steps like - login, account selection, entering the transfer amount, authentication, confirmation, etc..
Test Scenario: For the same banking application, a Test Scenario could be "Test the fund transfer feature," encompassing an overall functionality check. But without delving into the specific steps.
Here are the key differences:
- Test Cases verify specific features or functions through a series of actions, while Test Scenarios assess broader functionalities.
- Test Cases typically stem from Test Scenarios, whereas Test Scenarios are derived from documents like Business and System Requirement Specifications.
- Test Cases detail the aspects of 'what' and 'how' to test, whereas Test Scenarios primarily focus on 'what' to test.
- Test Cases involve detailed, specific actions (low-level), contrasting with the broader, general actions (high-level) in Test Scenarios.
- Test Cases demand more resources and time for execution, unlike Test Scenarios, which are more resource and time-efficient.
Conclusion
Test Cases outline the testing strategy, process, preconditions, and outcomes. They resemble a recipe, giving instructions for testing each software feature. Conversely, Test Scenarios classify features or functions for testing (what features or functions need testing). They provide a broader view, similar to a menu. Outlining what dishes (features) are available without detailing the specific ingredients or preparation steps.
FAQs of Difference Between Test Cases and Test Scenarios
What Are the Typical Pitfalls in Writing Test Cases?
Writing test cases often go awry with vague goals, unnecessary complexity, or overlooking edge cases. So, be clear and concise.
Is Automating Test Scenarios Feasible Like Test Cases?
βAutomating test scenarios is possible, though it demands thoughtful planning to ensure extensive and adequate testing coverage.
In Agile, What's the Role of Test Cases?
βAgile methodologies heavily rely on test cases for ongoing testing and integration, which is crucial for swiftly spotting and resolving bugs.
The Consequences of Inadequate Test Cases: What Are They?
βInadequately crafted test cases often miss crucial bugs, leading to incomplete testing and potentially causing the software to fail, frustrating users.
Why Distinguish Between Test Cases vs Test Scenarios?
βDifferentiating these two helps streamline testing processes, ensuring both detailed function checks and overall feature assessments are conducted.
Between test cases and test scenarios, which one to utilize in different circumstances?
Use 'test case' when you need thorough instructions for how to test a particular feature or function. Opt for a 'test scenario' when you need a general description of how the software feature should function or operate.
What Common Ground Do Test Cases and Scenarios Share?
Both test cases and scenarios play crucial roles in confirming an application's proper functionality despite their different approaches.
Anshuman Singh is an accomplished content writer with over three years of experience specializing in cybersecurity, cloud computing, networking, and software testing. Known for his clear, concise, and informative wr... Read Full Bio