Understanding Efficient Market Hypothesis and Its Forms

The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) is a type of financial theory that states that asset prices fully reflect all available information. As per EMH, stocks always trade at fair value on stock exchanges, making it impossible for investors to either buy undervalued stocks or sell stocks for inflated prices. 

 

Table of Contents

• What is Efficient Market Hypothesis?
• Efficient Market Hypothesis and Its Forms
• Is Efficient Market Hypothesis True?
• When is Efficient Market Hypothesis Used?
• How to Test Efficient Market Hypothesis?
• Efficient Market Hypothesis vs fundamental and technical analysis

What is Efficient Market Hypothesis?

Imagine you're at a marketplace where everyone is buying and selling fruits. In this market, every buyer and seller knows exactly how much every fruit should cost, based on its freshness, taste, and quantity available. Since everyone has all the information they need, the price you pay for an apple or a banana is always fair. No one can buy a fruit for a cheaper price today, knowing it will be worth more tomorrow, because everyone else knows what it's worth too.

The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) is similar, but instead of fruits, it's about stocks and other investments. It says that stock markets are like our ideal fruit market, where the prices of stocks reflect all available information. 

This means that the stock prices are always fair. It is impossible to buy undervalued stocks or sell stocks for inflated prices because everything known about the stock is already factored into its price. Therefore, trying to outsmart the market to make quick profits is very hard since you are not the only one with access to all the information.

Explore stock market courses

Who Developed Efficient Market Hypothesis?

The Efficient Market Hypothesis was created by economist Eugene Fama in the 1960s. He showed that it is tough to beat the stock market consistently because everything you need to know about a stock is already included in its price. This theory was introduced in his famous paper in 1970, making a big impact on how people understand and invest into the stock market.

Forms of Efficient Market Hypothesis

1. Weak Form Efficiency

The weak form of EMH asserts that all past trading information, including historical prices and volumes, is fully reflected in stock prices. Therefore, technical analysis, which tries to predict future stock prices based on past price movements and trends, cannot consistently outperform the market.

Implications: Investors cannot achieve superior returns using trading strategies based on historical price data alone.

2. Semi-Strong Form Efficiency

This form suggests that stock prices include all past trading information and publicly available information. This includes news releases, financial statements, economic data, etc. According to the semi-strong form, neither technical analysis nor fundamental analysis can consistently produce excess returns.

Implications: When new information becomes publicly available, stock prices adjust almost instantly and fully, making it impossible to gain an advantage through trading on this information.

3. Strong Form Efficiency

The strong form of EMH states that stock prices completely indicate both public and private information. This means that not even insiders with confidential information about their company can consistently achieve higher returns.

Implications: Markets are perfectly efficient, and no one can consistently outperform them through any analysis or access to inside information.

Is Efficient Market Hypothesis True?

The Efficient Market Hypothesis is not absolute. The real-world financial markets are subjected to inefficiencies due to human behaviour, regulatory changes, and unforeseen events. Whether this hypothesis is true or not depends on the perspective and the evidence considered. Here are some points in favour and against this hypothesis:

In Favour of Efficient Market Hypothesis:

• Empirical Evidence: Studies show that predicting stock prices in the short term is very difficult, supporting the idea that markets are efficient and prices indicate all available information.
• Market Performance: The difficulty most professional fund managers have in consistently beating the market indexes over the long term is often cited as evidence for market efficiency.

Against Efficient Market Hypothesis:

• Market Anomalies: There are documented instances where stock prices do not seem to reflect all available information, leading to patterns or anomalies that some investors can exploit.
• Behavioral Finance: This field studies how psychological influences and biases affect financial markets and decision-making, suggesting that human behavior can lead markets to be inefficient.
• Financial Crises: The occurrence of financial bubbles and crashes, where stock prices soar above or fall well below their true values, poses challenges to the EMH. These events suggest that markets can sometimes be driven by irrational factors rather than all-available information.

When is Efficient Market Hypothesis Used?

The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) is used in the fields of finance and investment, influencing both theoretical research and practical decision-making. Here are some of the key situations where EMH is relevant:

1. Investment Strategy Development: Investors and financial analysts use EMH to shape their investment strategies. For example, if one believes in strong market efficiency, they might opt for passive investment strategies, such as index fund investing, rather than attempting to outperform the market via active stock selection or market timing.
2. Portfolio Management: Portfolio managers consider EMH when making decisions about asset allocation and diversification. The hypothesis suggests that diversifying across a broad market index can be a more effective strategy than trying to pick individual winners.
3. Academic Research: EMH is a foundational theory in finance, prompting extensive academic research into market behavior, anomalies, and the degree to which markets reflect all available information. This research helps in understanding how markets operate and in developing new financial models.
4. Financial Regulation and Policy Making: Regulators and policymakers use the principles underlying EMH to design and implement regulations that aim to improve market transparency and fairness, under the assumption that well-informed markets are more efficient.
5. Corporate Finance: In corporate finance decisions, such as initial public offerings (IPOs), mergers, and acquisitions, EMH informs the understanding of how information disclosure and market reactions can affect company valuations.
6. Risk Management: Understanding market efficiency is crucial for risk management practices, as it influences the expectations about market volatility and the unpredictability of stock returns.
7. Behavioral Finance Analysis: While EMH posits that markets are efficient, the field of behavioral finance often uses it as a benchmark to explore how psychological factors cause deviations from market efficiency.

Explore:

Finance courses

Risk management courses

Corporate finance courses

How to Test Efficient Market Hypothesis?

There are several methods researchers and analysts use to test the EMH, each focusing on different aspects of market behavior. Here's a simplified overview of the main approaches:

1. Event Studies: This method analyzes how quickly and accurately stock prices adjust to new information. By examining the stock price movements before and after significant corporate events (like earnings announcements, mergers, or regulatory changes), researchers can assess if prices adjust in an efficient manner, consistent with the EMH.
2. Analysis of Returns: Testing for patterns in stock returns that persistently beat the market can challenge the EMH. If investors can consistently earn higher than expected returns using information that was publicly available, it suggests the market is not fully efficient.
3. Behavioral Biases: By identifying and analyzing instances where investor behaviour deviates from rationality due to psychological biases, researchers can test the boundaries of market efficiency. Common biases include overconfidence, overreaction, and herd behaviour.
4. Market Anomalies: Identifying market anomalies, such as the January effect (where stocks have historically performed better in January than in other months) or momentum effects (where stocks that have performed well in the past continue to perform well), can provide evidence against market efficiency.
5. Comparative Studies: Comparing the efficiency of different markets or segments within a market (e.g., comparing developed markets to emerging markets) can determine the factors that contribute to market efficiency and how they vary across different environments.

Efficient Market Hypothesis vs Fundamental and Technical Analysis

Parameter	Efficient Market Hypothesis	Fundamental Analysis	Technical Analysis
Core Principle	Stock prices reflect all available information and are priced accurately.	It is possible that stock prices deviate from their true value based on financials and market conditions.	Stock prices move in trends that can be predicted through past price patterns and volumes.
Market Efficiency	Assumes markets are efficient.	Operates on the assumption that markets can be inefficient.	Assumes inefficiencies in how prices reflect past information.
Information Used	All information (past, public, and even private in its strongest form).	Publicly available information like earnings reports, economic indicators.	Historical prices and volumes.
Goal	To understand or prove market behavior.	To identify undervalued or overvalued stocks.	To predict future stock price movements.
Investment Strategy	Passive investment strategies (e.g., index funds).	Active selection based on valuation.	Active trading based on price patterns.
Implication for Investors	Beating the market consistently is not possible.	Investors can identify mispriced stocks and profit from them.	Profits can be made by predicting and following trends.
Evidence/Analysis Method	Empirical studies, statistical analysis.	Financial statement analysis, industry/sector analysis.	Chart patterns, technical indicators.