2 Videos,

6 Photos

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Courses and Fees 2025

Q: Is B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur a good choice?

{Source: B.A. LL.B. (Hons) students & alumni} Based on the feedback from students and alumni, here's what you can expect: Pros: * Good faculty-to-student ratio (21:1) * Well-educated and experienced faculty members * Friendly and approachable professors * Good quality education, with a focus on both theoretical and practical aspects * Opportunities for internships and research projects * Various extracurricular activities, such as mooting, debating, and cultural programs * Decent campus surroundings and connectivity Cons: * Limited infrastructure, as the university operates from a rented campus temporarily * No placement records yet, as the first batch hasn't graduated * Limited recreational facilities, such as a poor maintenance of cricket field and limited indoor games options * Mess food may vary in taste and quality Placement and Career Prospects: * While there are no placement records yet, the university claims that the first batch will place in 2021, indicating promising career prospects * The internship placement cell helps students secure internships in reputed firms * Many students have secured internships independently Overall: While B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur has some limitations due to its temporary rental campus setup, the university seems to offer a good educational experience with supportive faculty and opportunities for growth. Once the permanent campus is built, the infrastructure issues are likely to be resolved. Considering the lack of placement records, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully before making a decision. However, for those interested in pursuing a career in law, this university might be worth exploring.

Q: Question: How is the course curriculum for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur?

{Source: B.A. LL.B. (Hons) students & alumni} Course Curriculum Structure for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur The course curriculum at NLU Jabalpur for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) is structured to provide students with a comprehensive education in law. Here are the key features: * Exams: Semesters are divided into mid-semester and end-semester exams, with a pass percentage requirement of 50% for both written exams and projects/vivas. * Projects and Vivas: Field visits and practical projects are an integral part of the curriculum, enabling students to apply theoretical knowledge to real-world scenarios. * Research Papers and Internships: Every semester, students are required to submit research papers and participate in internships, preparing them for the demands of the legal profession. * Curriculum Drafting: The curriculum is carefully crafted to incorporate relevant contemporary issues, ensuring students develop problem-solving skills and adaptability to changing societal needs. * Teaching Staff: Faculty members are highly qualified, knowledgeable, and supportive, with many having experience teaching at top National Law Universities. By following this structured curriculum, students at NLU Jabalpur receive a well-rounded education that prepares them for success in the legal profession.

Q: How does the placement cell for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur assist students in getting placed?

{Source: B.A. LL.B. (Hons) students & alumni} Placement Cell Assistance for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Students at NLU Jabalpur The Internship and Placement cell (IAPC) at NLU Jabalpur assists students in securing internships and placements. Although the college has not had a graduating batch yet, the IAPC has been actively working to place students. Almost every student from the first internship break of our batch has secured an internship. * The placement cell aids students who are unable to secure good internships on their own. * Internship is mandatory by the placement cell after every semester. * The college aims to secure student internships, especially those interested in judiciary and litigation. Note: As the college is still relatively new, there is limited data available on placements. However, the placement cell's efforts to secure internships and future placements are evident.

Jabalpur

3.5 /5

(8 Reviews)

107 Student Q&A

Public/Government University
Estd. 2018

Last updated on 9 Jan '25

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
What’s new?

The CLAT result 2025 has been declared for 5-year Integrated BA LLB (Hons) course. Candidates can log in and download their scorecards from the official website. The CLAT 2025 counselling registrations are also open now, and the last date is Dec 20, 2024.

NLU Jabalpur Cut off 2023: Second Provisional Allocation List (Released)

CNLU has released the Second Provisional Allocation List on Jan 27, 2023. Registered candidates for CLAT 2023 counselling will be called by the respective NLUs through five provisional merit lists, each released by the Consortium of CLAT. Candidates, who have been allocated a seat in the second list and applied for revision, should check the status of their seat in the third list. Those, who have been allotted a seat in the NLU Jabalpur Second Provisional Allotment List, must complete the process of exercising any one of the actions mentioned below:

Accept the allotted seat
Apply for Revise
Exit from the CLAT admission process

Below mentioned are the opening and closing ranks as per the vertical reservation for the General category of NLU Jabalpur cut off lists 2023:

Second Provisional Allotment List 2023
Course Name	Opening Rank	Closing Rank
BA LLB (Hons)	1733	1792

Read more: NLU Jabalpur Cutoff 2023

NLU Jabalpur BA LLB (Hons) Admission Dates 2023

Dharmashastra National Law University Jabalpur offers admission on the basis on valid CLAT scores. Some of the important dates related to the same are given below:

UPCOMING EVENTS
Second Allotment List: Release date	27 Jan ‘23
Third Allotment List: Release date	25 May ‘23
Fourth Allotment List: Release date	5 Jun ‘23
Fifth and Final Allotment List: Release date	15 Jun ‘23

Stories

Admission Process

Eligibility & Cut Offs

NLU Jabalpur Overview

Table of content

Dharmashastra National Law University B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Eligibility and Highlights 2025
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Popular courses
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Admission dates 2025
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Admission cutoff 2025
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Curriculum
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Seats
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Placements 2025
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Student Reviews
NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Admission FAQs

Dharmashastra National Law University B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Eligibility and Highlights 2025

In the stream of Law, Dharmashastra National Law University offers a B.A. LL.B. (Hons) programme to the students. Offered at UG level, this course is offered for a duration of 5 years. Dharmashastra National Law University B.A. LL.B. (Hons) admissions are offered based on students' performance in the CLAT, CBSE 12th, ISC, and MPBSE 12th examination. The college offers an intake capacity of 134 seats to the students. Moreover, students must also ensure to fulfil the following eligibility criteria to confirm their chances of admission:

Course	Eligibility
B.A. LL.B. (Hons)	45% in XII for general category students.

Dharmashastra National Law University B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Fees 2025

For admission, students are required to pay the Dharmashastra National Law University fee as prescribed by the university. The total fees for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) include numerous components, such as hostel fees, tuition fees, examination fees, etc. As per the structure, the total tuition fee for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) is INR 5,50,000. The given fee information is taken from official sources, such as the website or sanctioning body. Hence, it is indicative.

Eligibility Criteria

Accepted Exam

+3 more

10+2 score45%

Return on Investment

Total Tuition Fees₹ 5.5L

Commonly asked questions
On Highlights

Q: Is B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur a good choice?

{Source: B.A. LL.B. (Hons) students & alumni}

Based on the feedback from students and alumni, here's what you can expect:

Pros:

* Good faculty-to-student ratio (21:1)
* Well-educated and experienced faculty members
* Friendly and approachable professors
* Good quality education, with a focus on both theoretical and practical aspects
* Opportunities for internships and research projects
* Various extracurricular activities, such as mooting, debating, and cultural programs
* Decent campus surroundings and connectivity

Cons:

* Limited infrastructure, as the university operates from a rented campus temporarily
* No placement records yet, as the first batch hasn't graduated
* Limited recreational facilities, such as a poor maintenance of cricket field and limited indoor games options
* Mess food may vary in taste and quality

Placement and Career Prospects:

* While there are no placement records yet, the university claims that the first batch will place in 2021, indicating promising career prospects
* The internship placement cell helps students secure internships in reputed firms
* Many students have secured internships independently

Overall:

While B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur has some limitations due to its temporary rental campus setup, the university seems to offer a good educational experience with supportive faculty and opportunities for growth. Once the permanent campus is built, the infrastructure issues are likely to be resolved. Considering the lack of placement records, it's essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully before making a decision. However, for those interested in pursuing a career in law, this university might be worth exploring.

Upvote

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Popular courses

Search for specializations in B.A. LL.B. (Hons)

Filter

Streams

Mode of Study Down Arrow Icon

Course Level Down Arrow Icon

Location

+3 More

Showing 1 Course

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.)

3.55 years

Seats Offered

134

Exams Accepted

Median Salary

– / –

Total Tuition Fees

₹5.5 L

Get Fee Details

Trending

Explore popular private colleges

Students looking for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) courses have shown interest these colleges

School of Legal Studies, CMR University institute image

Bangalore

Courses Offered1 course4.2

Total Fees Range₹7.5 L

Also preferred by students

SRM University, Delhi-NCR, Sonepat, Haryana (SRMUH) institute image

Sonepat

Courses Offered1 course3.6

Total Fees Range₹7.5 L

Also preferred by students

Jaipur National University institute image

Jaipur

Courses Offered1 course3.5

Total Fees Range₹6.32 L

Also preferred by students

Amity University, Gwalior institute image

Gwalior

Courses Offered1 course4.0

Total Fees Range₹5.2 L

Also preferred by students

Want better recommendations?

There is a 90% more chance of getting best college recommendations by sharing preferences.

+ Add preferences

Amity University, Raipur institute image

Raipur

Courses Offered1 course3.7

Total Fees Range₹7.5 L

Also preferred by students

Amity University, Noida institute image

Noida

Courses Offered1 course4.1

Total Fees Range₹19 L

Positive review ratings provided by students

Amity University, Gurugram institute image

Gurgaon

Courses Offered1 course4.5

Total Fees Range₹10.9 L

Also preferred by students

Amity University, Lucknow institute image

Lucknow

Courses Offered1 course3.8

Total Fees Range₹11.4 L

Also preferred by students

Amity University, Mumbai institute image

Mumbai

Courses Offered1 course3.8

Total Fees Range₹10.3 L

Also preferred by students

Adamas University institute image

Kolkata

Courses Offered1 course4.0

Total Fees Range₹8.75 L

Also preferred by students

View allCollections

Is this recommendation relevant?

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Admission dates 2025

Dates	Past Events
9 Dec '24 - 20 Dec '24	CLAT 2025 Counselling Registration
11 Dec '24 - 20 Dec '24	CLAT 2025 Counselling Registration (Begins)

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Admission cutoff 2025

Cut Off 2024 for CLAT: Year-Wise rank Accordion Icon V3

CLAT Last Round Closing Rank (General-All India)

Course	2022	2023	2024
B.A. LL.B. (Hons.)	2262	2698	1824

View all cut-off

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Curriculum

Specialization	Curriculum
B.A. LL.B. (Hons.)

Commonly asked questions
On Curriculum

Q: Question: How is the course curriculum for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur?

{Source: B.A. LL.B. (Hons) students & alumni}

Course Curriculum Structure for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur

The course curriculum at NLU Jabalpur for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) is structured to provide students with a comprehensive education in law. Here are the key features:

* Exams: Semesters are divided into mid-semester and end-semester exams, with a pass percentage requirement of 50% for both written exams and projects/vivas.
* Projects and Vivas: Field visits and practical projects are an integral part of the curriculum, enabling students to apply theoretical knowledge to real-world scenarios.
* Research Papers and Internships: Every semester, students are required to submit research papers and participate in internships, preparing them for the demands of the legal profession.
* Curriculum Drafting: The curriculum is carefully crafted to incorporate relevant contemporary issues, ensuring students develop problem-solving skills and adaptability to changing societal needs.
* Teaching Staff: Faculty members are highly qualified, knowledgeable, and supportive, with many having experience teaching at top National Law Universities.

By following this structured curriculum, students at NLU Jabalpur receive a well-rounded education that prepares them for success in the legal profession.

Upvote

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Seats

134

Total Seats Available

Courses	Seats
B.A. LL.B. (Hons.)	134

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Placements 2025

View placement details

Commonly asked questions
On Placements

Q: How does the placement cell for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) at NLU Jabalpur assist students in getting placed?

{Source: B.A. LL.B. (Hons) students & alumni}

Placement Cell Assistance for B.A. LL.B. (Hons) Students at NLU Jabalpur

The Internship and Placement cell (IAPC) at NLU Jabalpur assists students in securing internships and placements. Although the college has not had a graduating batch yet, the IAPC has been actively working to place students. Almost every student from the first internship break of our batch has secured an internship.

* The placement cell aids students who are unable to secure good internships on their own.
* Internship is mandatory by the placement cell after every semester.
* The college aims to secure student internships, especially those interested in judiciary and litigation.

Note: As the college is still relatively new, there is limited data available on placements. However, the placement cell's efforts to secure internships and future placements are evident.

Upvote

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Explore Other Courses

LL.M.

View all courses ->

NLU Jabalpur B.A. LL.B. (Hons)
Students Ratings & Reviews

3.5/5

8 Verified Reviews Info Icon

4-5
1
3-4
5
2-3
2

Placements3.3

Infrastructure3.5

Faculty & Course4.3

Campus Life3.6

Value for Money3.1

Anonymous

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) - Batch of 2021

2Placements2Infrastructure4Faculty4Crowd & Campus Life3Value for Money

Our university has good growth and is still developing.

Placements: At present, there are almost 660 students in the university including the five B.A., LL.B., and LL.M batches. Since the university was established in 2018, there were no placements offered to anyone. The senior batch graduated in 2023. The recruitment drive was conducted in our college in which about 45 students got selected.

Infrastructure: The university is at present running in on a rented campus at Bharat Ratna Bhimrao Ambedkar Institute of Telecom Training, Jabalpur. The university had two cad blocks. There was an adequate number of classrooms and each class had Wi-Fi and projector facilities. Since it is a residential university, there were three hostels. There were two hostels for boys and one hostel for girls. Hostels were in better condition. Wi-Fi was available in each wing and corridor. Each of the hostels has badminton courts inside it. There was a ground of around 450 m in which other sports were organised. The food was served by caterers for which tenders were floated by the mess committee run by students.

Faculty: Teachers were well-qualified and had good knowledge of their subjects and other subjects. They were student-friendly. The course curriculum was prepared according to the relevant present situation of the social, political, and economic problems. Every semester, two exams were held, which were the mid-semester exam and the end-semester exam. The pass percentage was 50% for both exams.

Reviewed on 25 Sep 2022Read More

Anonymous

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) - Batch of 2026

2.8

3Placements3Infrastructure3Faculty3Crowd & Campus Life2Value for Money

Come to this college only if you can afford a high fee with substandard facilities.

Placements: Anyone cannot make a claim regarding the job prospect and placement because the first batch of our college students has not yet been out. Although the college has a placement and internship cell that aids the students in finding internships with various advocates and the state legal service authority.

Infrastructure: You shouldn't expect much from the campus considering that the university is currently functional from a rented campus. We have air-conditioned classrooms with projectors. Although reading rooms and e-library suffice our purposes, the college library has to be expanded. The sports facilities are not very excellent. It includes a poorly maintained cricket field, and chess, carrom, table tennis for indoor games. Our hostels are properly maintained by staff members and hostel supervisors who are very friendly with the students. Students are provided with one bed, one table and chair, three almirahs, fans and coolers in each room, and two windows in each room to ensure adequate air circulation. The college also offers VIP rooms which are more expensive than normal rooms and have air-conditioners. Hostels are reasonably priced at Rs.37000 per year. If you are doing an internship in Jabalpur, you are allowed to stay in the hostels during your internship. The college has a dispensary and a physician is available there from 10 AM - 5 PM. Apart from this, there is an ambulance facility for 24/7. Talking about mess, reviews of students changes according to their previous food habits.

Faculty: According to the college brochure, the current student-faculty ratio is 21:1. Law faculty members are highly qualified and have extensive experience in their respective fields. The majority of our faculty members are graduates from various top national law universities. The most amazing aspect of DNLU is its teaching staff. The professors are extremely friendly and willing to assist any student who approaches them. Every semester, there are two exams namely, the mid-semester and the end semester. Since this is a national law university, it maintains a standard of question papers.

Other: Since this was the first semester after lockdown we could not do many events and fests. Students arranged a college reopening party and a Holi celebration was also there. Two-three clubs have been created but they are not very functional. I am sure that these clubs will become more active. The crowd is good and you can find seniors who are very helpful easily. Campus is surrounded by greenery and since our campus is in Army Cantonment Zone, the security in DNLU is up to the mark. Students can avail various government and private scholarships. There is a dedicated cell in the university for assisting students in getting scholarship. Apart from this, our college also provides financial aid for students who are not getting any scholarship and are facing hardship in paying the fees. But the corpus for this fund is very low than the need.

Reviewed on 4 Jul 2022Read More

Mahak Jain Verified Icon

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) - Batch of 2027

3.8

4Placements3Infrastructure4Faculty4Crowd & Campus Life4Value for Money

My College, My Jannat, My Duniya.

Placements: Percentage of students placed: 60-70% Salary Package: 15-18 LPA Average Package: 7-10 LPA Top Recruiter companies: Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas, AZB & Partners, Khaitan & Co., Luthra and Luthra Law Offices, Trilegal Around 80-90% of students secured internships during the course. Internship Locations: Tier 1, 2, and 3 law firms.

Infrastructure: The infrastructure for both the course and hostel is well-equipped and designed to support students' needs. The campus offers high-speed Wi-Fi throughout, ensuring seamless access to online resources. The department has state-of-the-art labs with modern technology that support practical learning and research.

Faculty: The faculty members in the course are highly qualified, experienced, and dedicated to providing quality education. They are not only knowledgeable in their respective fields but also approachable and willing to provide additional support to students whenever needed. The teaching quality is exceptional, with professors employing diverse teaching methods, including interactive lectures and group discussions.

Other: I chose this course because of my deep interest in Law and its potential to open up various career opportunities.

Reviewed on 22 Dec 2024Read More

Anonymous

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) - Batch of 2026

3.6

2Placements5Infrastructure5Faculty3Crowd & Campus Life3Value for Money

It is a new college with lot of potential.

Placements: So right now, our 5th-year batch has not yet passed out so we can't say much about placements. But after this batch passes out, we will have the opportunities for sure. Internship is also mandatory by placement cell after every semester. If you are from Madhya Pradesh and want to do judiciary and litigation, it is the best choice for you.

Infrastructure: The infrastructure of our college is rented but the new campus will be ready in 1-2 years. The location of the college is very good where the rented campus is situated. All the basic facilities are provided in the hostel. You will get 2 students accommodation in our college hostel.

Faculty: Faculty members are well educated and very good in our college. We also have visiting faculty members who come on a monthly basis. Course curriculum is according to BCA rules.

Reviewed on 19 Mar 2022Read More

Alok Bagri Verified Icon

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) - Batch of 2026

3.8

4Placements3Infrastructure4Faculty4Crowd & Campus Life4Value for Money

It has highly motivated students and faculty who are keen to take the college to greater heights.

Placements: We have a student-oriented Internship and Placement cell (IAPC) in our college which looks after internships and placements. As the college was established in 2018 only, the founding batch is yet to be passed out, so there are not any statistics available about the placements. But the IAPC has been working actively to secure student internships. We are given an internship break after every semester and in the first internship break of our batch, almost every student from our batch has secured an internship.

Infrastructure: The college is currently functioning in Bharat Ratna Bhim Rao Ambedkar Institute of Telecom Training (BRBRAITT) located in South Civil Lines Jabalpur. The college has been allotted 120 acres of land to develop its campus but the construction is yet to be started. There are separate hostels for boys and girls in which twin sharing rooms are available. The academic block and hostels both have Wi-Fi facilities.

Faculty: Faculty members in our college are highly qualified, knowledgeable, and helpful. In these tough times, classes have been conducted in online mode but despite this challenge, the learning has not been compromised. Every teacher adopts its method to make the class interactive and encourage students to clear their doubts in the class itself or through mails. The curriculum adopted by the college is appropriate and makes students ready for the challenges they face in the legal profession as it does not only revolve around the books but also includes writing research papers and internships every semester.

Other: DNLU has various research centers and committees including the charm of law schools, moot court committee in which students can join according to their interests. The college also conducts Justice G. P. Singh memorial national moot court competition annually.

Reviewed on 7 Jan 2022Read More

Aanemesh Singh Verified Icon

B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) - Batch of 2024

4.4

5Placements5Infrastructure5Faculty4Crowd & Campus Life3Value for Money

Faculty is good and supportive, infrastructure is work in progress, placements will be known.

Placements: Since this is a newly established university, there is no knowledge about placement. But since it is National Law University, no doubt the placements will be great and will be known soon when the foundation batch will be placed. The foundation batch will places in 2021, that is, this year.

Infrastructure: Our NLU has the biggest campus of 120 Acre and is currently under construction and surely it will be a modern infrastructure as per today needs. It will have a gym, sports room, modern facilities like Wi-Fi, canteen and so more. Hostels will be great too.

Faculty: Faculty is great and experienced. Every faculty has some experience and almost every teacher has an experience of teaching at National Law University, the syllabus of the course is well drafted, only issue the students face is regarding study material.

Reviewed on 22 Jul 2021Read More

View All 8 Reviews

NLU Jabalpur
Admission FAQs

Q: What was the highest package offered at Dharmashastra National Law University for LL.B.?

Notably, NLU Delhi has set a high standard by providing the highest package of Rs. 19,00,000 per annum according to the latest available data. Top recruiters for NLUs encompass premier law firms, corporate entities, government agencies, and public sector organizations.

Among the top 30 law colleges in the country as per the NIRF 2023 law college rankings, 11 NLUs find a place. The median salary, a figure representing the average NLU placement packages, ranges between Rs. 6 Lakhs pa to 10 Lakhs pa in NLUs that have placed students in different organisations.

Upvote

NLU Jabalpur

Student Forum

Anything you would want to ask experts?

Write here...

Which is best course offered by Dharmashastra National Law University?

Answered 3 months ago

Dharmashastra National Law University (DNLU) in Jabalpur is well-known for its BA LLB (Hons) program, which offers a comprehensive curriculum and a strong emphasis on practical legal training. They also offer well-regarded LLM programs.

Satyasrikranthi

Contributor-Level 10

Is Dharmashastra National Law University Tier 1 or Tier 2?

Answered 4 months ago

Dharmashastra National Law University (DNLU) in Jabalpur is generally considered a Tier 2 law school. It has a growing reputation and offers quality legal education, but it doesn't yet have the same level of national recognition or historical prestige as the top Tier 1 law schools like the National

...more

Diksha Joshi

Contributor-Level 9

Is Dharmashastra National Law University good for Master of Law (LL.M.)?

Answered 5 months ago

The LL.M programme at Dharmashastra National Law University is considered one of the best law courses offered in the state. It is seen as a good choice as DNLU has great academic program, detailed curriculum, internship opportunities, detailed specifications, world class infrastructure, amazing facu

...more

Srishti

Contributor-Level 10

Can I get direct admission at Dharmashastra National Law University for LL.M.?

Answered 5 months ago

Generally speaking, Dharmashastra National Law University's (DNLU) LL.M. programme does not offer direct admission. In addition to meeting certain eligibility requirements, admissions decisions are usually made based on candidates' performance on entrance exams such as the university's own entrance

...more

Muskan

Contributor-Level 10

Is pursuing LLL.M. at Dharmashastra National Law University expensive?

Answered 5 months ago

The cost of an LL.M. at Dharmashastra National Law University (DNLU) is moderate when compared to private law schools, but somewhat high when compared to general universities. Since tuition, housing costs, and other associated costs are included in the fee structure, many students view it as a major

...more

Muskan

Contributor-Level 10

Content authored by: