J. Z. Shah Arts and H. P. Desai Commerce College Reviews on Placements, Faculty & Facilities ,Surat

Average rating of this institute

Overall Rating (Out of 5)

4.1

Based on 5 Verified Reviews
Component Ratings (Out of 5)
Placements
4.0
Infrastructure
4.4
Faculty & Course Curriculum
4.4
Crowd & Campus Life
4.0
Value for Money
3.6
The Verified badge indicates that the reviewer's details have been verified by Shiksha, and reviewers are bona fide students of this college. These reviews and ratings have been given by students. Shiksha does not endorse the same. Out of 8 published reviews, 5 reviews are verified.

Filter By

Avg. Rating
>3-4>4-5
Sort By
RelevanceRecencyYear Of GraduationHighest RatingLowest Rating
Read reviews that mention
Recruiting CompaniesTop CompaniesPlacement TrainingInternshipsPlacement CellCTC OfferedRoles OfferedPercentage of Batch PlacedAverage Package OfferedHighest Package OfferedTop FacultyCourse Curriculum DesignFaculty Easily ApproachableQuality educationTeaching ExperienceSupportive FacultyKnowledge SharingOverall DevelopmentWell equiped Class RoomsLibraryTop InfrastructureHostel AvailableAir Conditioned CampusComputer CentreLaboratory FacilityBooks AvailableSports FestivalEvents OrganisedScholarship AvailableCultural FestivalTechnical FestivalsB.com PlacementsNumber of Companies VisitingInterview ProcessTechnical RoundsIT CompaniesLowest Package OfferedSales RoleFinance Roles Senior Batch PlacementsPedagogyPersonality DevelopmentIndustry ExposureLive ProjectsStudent InteractionCanteen and cafeteriaDigital ClassroomExtracurricular ActivityBeautiful CampusBasic AmentiesMedical FacilityLarge CampusCricket GroundGovernment CollegeVolleyBall CourtSports FacilityPlayGroundFootball groundCleanliness and HygieneView All
Very PositivePositiveNeutralNegativeVery Negative
M
Mukesh gohil | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2025
Reviewed on 29 Nov 2024
Verified
4.2
Placements 5 Infrastructure 5 Faculty & Course Curriculum 4 Crowd & Campus Life 4 Value for Money 3
It is the best college for commerce students.

Placements: Placement facilities are very good. Many companies visit our college every year for placements. Big companies like Tata, Reliance, and Divya Bhaskar hire many students. Our college organises placements every year for all students.

Was this review helpful YesNo  
C
Chauhan Dharmesh | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2025
Reviewed on 20 Nov 2024
Verified
4.2
Placements 4 Infrastructure 5 Faculty & Course Curriculum 5 Crowd & Campus Life 4 Value for Money 3
A good environment with good staff.

Placements: As I am in my last year, I will go for interviews in December when companies come for placements. When I was in my second year, companies like Tata, Reliance, and Divya Bhaskar visited our college. They placed many students with good salary packages, so the placement facility is good in our college.

Was this review helpful YesNo  
K
Keyur Vekariya | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2022
Reviewed on 24 Sep 2024
Verified
4.2
Placements 4 Infrastructure 4 Faculty & Course Curriculum 5 Crowd & Campus Life 4 Value for Money 4
Our college provides the best quality education, best teachers, and extracurricular activities.

Placements: Around 55-60% of students were placed in my course. The highest package offered was 4 LPA, and the lowest was 1.2 LPA. The average package was around 1.2-1.5 LPA. The top recruiting companies for our course were TCS, HDB Finance, Axis Bank, and HDFC. Approximately 35% to 40% of students got internships in various companies such as HDB, TCS, and Axis Bank. The top roles offered were sales executive, junior manager, and relationship manager.

Was this review helpful YesNo  
V
Vasudev Vimalbhai ... | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2020
Reviewed on 1 May 2022
Verified
4.2
Placements 4 Infrastructure 4 Faculty & Course Curriculum 5 Crowd & Campus Life 4 Value for Money 4
It is the number one college in Surat for arts and commerce.

Placements: Around 20% to 30% of students were placed in different companies like TCS, ICICI Bank, and other local and regional companies. The salary packages offered by these companies to B.Com graduates were around 1.2 LPA to 1.5 LPA.

Was this review helpful YesNo  
M
Manish Makvana | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2021
Reviewed on 19 Sep 2021
Verified
3.6
Placements 3 Infrastructure 4 Faculty & Course Curriculum 3 Crowd & Campus Life 4 Value for Money 4
I am satisfied by considering fees, and infrastructure. But unsatisfied with quality of teaching.

Placements: Around 20% to 30% of the students get placed form college. The highest salary offered is Rs. 40,000 per month and the average salary offered is Rs. 20,000 per month. The lowest salary offered was Rs. 15,000 per month. Many companies like Airtel, Reliance, and L&T come to recruit students. Unfortunately, none of us got internships in any company. Top role offered was working as a junior accountant.

Was this review helpful YesNo  

The reviewer's details of the following reviews have not been verified yet.

G
Gopi Modi | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2022
Reviewed on 8 May 2023
3.8
Placements 4 Infrastructure 3 Faculty & Course Curriculum 4 Crowd & Campus Life 4 Value for Money 4
Review of J. Z. Shah Arts and H. P. Desai Commerce College.

Placements: Around 30-35% of students got placed in our college. The highest salary offered is Rs. 30,000 per month. Almost 30% of students got internships in accounting companies.

Was this review helpful YesNo  
V
Vaibhav Variya | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2019
Reviewed on 6 May 2021
4.2
Placements 5 Infrastructure 4 Faculty & Course Curriculum 4 Crowd & Campus Life 5 Value for Money 3
4 star facilities are available in the college along with experienced faculty members.

Placements: Around 92 percent of student are in this course and college . There is no package in this college as it is government approved. There is government recruiting, and other local companies recruitment. 30 percent students got internship in this course to the highest percentage students. College offers free course, scholarship and more offers.

Was this review helpful YesNo  
V
Vora Avkash | Bachelor of Commerce (B.Com.) - Batch of 2021
Reviewed on 12 Mar 2021
5.0
Placements 5 Infrastructure 5 Faculty & Course Curriculum 5 Crowd & Campus Life 5 Value for Money 5
Yes, the college provides all the necessary facilities.

Placements: Top recruiting companies are Ernst & young (EV) and KPMG India and KPMG global services, etc. 85 to 100 per cent of students got internships from our course in Ernst & Young (EV) companies.

Was this review helpful YesNo  

News & Updates

Latest NewsPopular News
Confused about which college or exam to opt for?
  • Chat with our counsellor
  • Get your personalised list of colleges & exams matching your preferences