Difference between Atom and Ion: Overview, Questions, Preparation

Structure of Atom 2021

Updated on Jun 4, 2024 16:11 IST

Matter is made of particles and how these particles react depends on their properties, so understanding the difference between atoms and ions is important to understand how reactions occur. In Class X and XI, this topic can have a weightage of 10 marks. 

What are Atoms and Ions?

An atom is defined as the smallest unit of matter which forms an element. Earlier thought to be indivisible, later experiments proved that atoms can in fact be broken down further into subatomic particles - the proton, neutron, and electrons. 

All atoms have the same number of electrons and protons and are therefore electrically neutral.

When an atom loses or gains electrons, they become charged. Such charged particles are called ions. They can be positively charged if electrons are lost and these are called cations, or negatively charged if electrons are gained, called anions. 

Differences between Atoms and Ions

Atom

Ion

Basic unit of an element.

An atom or molecule with a charge.

Have equal number of protons and electrons

Have an unequal number of protons and electrons.

Have a neutral charge

Can be positively or negatively charged

They are unstable due to incomplete valence shells and are highly reactive when independent. 

Exception: noble gases

They have a complete valence shell and can exist independently with high stability.

Can form covalent or ionic bonds

Can only form ionic bonds

Atoms form molecules

Ions can be polyatomic or monoatomic. They can also form lattice networks 

Not attracted to electrical field

Can be attracted to an electrical field depending on the charge of the ion

For Class 10 Ions form ionic compounds when elements react through their tendency to form complete valence shells.

For eg.

Here the electron in the outer valence shell of sodium is lost to give a positively charged Sodium cation.

Chlorine gains an electron to form chloride anion.

The two ions form an ionic bond to give a stable Sodium Chloride molecule.

Such ionic compounds are aggregates of ions. They are held by strong electrostatic forces of attraction. 

For Class 11

The first atomic theory was provided by John Dalton and proposed that the atom was indivisible. Later experiments proved that atoms were in fact made up of protons, neutrons and electrons. 

Many models of the atom were proposed, until settled upon by the quantum mechanical model of the atom. According to this, the electrons in the atom are said to be arranged in shells which are further divided into subshells and orbitals. The electrons in the completely filled shells are known as core electrons, and the electrons that are added to the electronic shell with the highest principal quantum number are called valence electrons.

Here is how the configuration of the sodium ion will look like when it loses its outer electron.

Illustrated Examples

1. Show the formation of magnesium chloride with the help of electron dot structures. What are the ions present in it?

Answer:

The ions are: cation:  Mg+2  

                       anion: Cl⁻

2. Which of the following are isoelectronic species, i.e., those having the same number

of electrons?

Na+, K+, Mg2+, Ca2+, S2–, Ar.

Answer: Na+, Mg2+, Ca2+

                Ar, S2– and K+

3. Write the electronic configurations of the following ions: (a) H– (b) Na+ (c) O2–

(d) F–

Answer: (a) 1s2 (b) 1s2 2s2 2p6; (c) 1s22s22p6 (d) 1s22s22p6

FAQs on Difference between Atom and Ion

Q: Can all atoms be ions?

A:  Technically all atoms except that of the noble gases can form ions, but all ions are not atoms. Some ions can be polyatomic, meaning they are made of aggregates of atoms for eg. Phosphate ions PO₄³⁻

Q: What determines the charge of a monoatomic ion?

A:  As ions are formed because of atoms gaining or losing electrons to reach a stable octet configuration or to a closed shell, the charge of an atom can be determined by the number of electrons needed to be lost or gained to reach that number. Eg. Calcium atom with 20 electrons needs to lose 2 electrons to achieve a closed outer shell, making it a calcium ion with a charge of +2.  

Q: Is an ion different than their parent atom?

A:  Yes, ions can be smaller or larger than their parent atom. Cations are generally smaller as they lose the outer shell of electrons and are held more tightly together; whereas anions are larger than their parent atom.

Q: Is there a difference between covalent compounds and ionic compounds?

A:  The atoms in covalent compounds share electrons to form a molecule, whereas ionic compounds give and take electrons to form an aggregate of atoms. Covalent compounds can not transmit electricity as they do not have free electrons, however, ionic compounds can.

Q: Can a polyatomic ion have different kinds of bonds?

A:  Yes, polyatomic ions like the ammonium ion (NH₄⁺) has the nitrogen atom form 3 covalent bonds with hydrogen and one ionic bond with a proton, to form the ammonium ion which acts like a cation in reactions and even forms ionic compounds with other anions, such as Ammonium Chloride (NH₄Cl)

News & Updates

Latest NewsPopular News
qna

Structure of Atom Exam

Student Forum

chatAnything you would want to ask experts?
Write here...